Home > Opinion > Sometimes Tracked Vehicles Get Stuck Too!

Sometimes Tracked Vehicles Get Stuck Too!

Library image of a Challenger 2 main battle tank bogged in when crossing soft ground during a NATO eFP mission training exercise in Estonia ~ it was stuck so fast in peat it needed to be recovered by another tank [© Bob Morrison]

Sometimes it makes me chuckle when keyboard warriors debate on wheels versus tracks as sometimes tracked vehicles get stuck too, writes Bob Morrison.


There is potential UK requirement for a new self-propelled artillery system to replace the Royal Artillery’s now 30 year old L131 (AS-90) 155mm self-propelled howitzer and the subject of which system, wheeled or tracked, should be procured is causing some ‘armchair generals’ to put their keyboards into overdrive.

Even a light 4×4 with good off-road ability, like this Danish Geländewagen photographed several years ago in Poland, can get stuck crossing soft ground if the driver misreads the terrain [©BM]

A few of those professing to be experts (‘ex’ = has-been and ‘spurt’ = drip under pressure) on t’internet, including the odd individuals with a soupçon of military service in the distant past who are paid lobbyists for defence suppliers, seem unwilling to accept that neither a solely wheeled nor tracked solution is actually what is needed because both methods of delivering a heavy howitzer to the gun line have distinct disadvantages. Conversely, both wheeled and tracked solutions offer certain advantages (mostly speed and range versus better all-terrain ability) that the other does not so, possibly two different vehicle types are what the British Army really needs; assuming, of course, that the Treasury is given little say in the decision. Alternatively, possibly a modular solution with two base transporters and an interchangeable artillery module, as in Wheeled Boxer plus Tracked Boxer, might be worth considering; however whether or not such a compromise (they say the camel started life as a horse designed by a defence procurement committee) could result in cost savings while offering the same capabilities as a ‘different horses for different courses’ solution is debatable.

There is a very good reason why wheeled recovery vehicles, like this British Army MAN SV, exist in the inventory ~ the clue is in the name [©BM]
Tracked vehicle formations need to be accompanied by similar ability recovery vehicles ~ these two seen on Op CABRIT in Estonia are based on Challenger and Warrior [©BM]
Wheeled artillery systems, like these Polish DITA self-propelled howitzers on a long range road move through Lithuania, offer much greater speed and range than tracked equivalents [©BM]
Tracked artillery systems, like this British AS-90 deployed on Op CABRIT in 2019, offer better off-road ability than wheels but usually need a tank transporter for long distance moves [©BM]

Well that’s my inconsequential tuppence-worth. I’m not an expert but, unlike some twittering keyboard warriors, I do occasionally get out in the field to watch the military forces of several nations on exercises and deployments… and I’ve also got stuck off-tarmac in more vehicle and terrain types (from Arctic to Desert to High Veldt, with everything in-between) than I usually admit to.

~ $ ~

Enjoy the festive season!


You may also like
First Saab Airborne Surveillance System for Poland
Slovenian Mountain Warfare Soldier Kit
Rheinmetall LUNA NG Ordered by Bundeswehr
Royal Navy Minehunters Sold to Romania